Church & Nonprofit Payroll: The 2025 Compliance Guide (W-2/1099, Clergy Allowances, Multi-State)
- W-2 for staff, 1099 only when it’s truly a non-employee engagement.
- Use designated fields to track clergy housing allowance (where applicable).
- We run payroll, file federal/state taxes, and e-deliver W-2/1099.
- Flat pricing: $50 + $7/employee (Full) or $40 + $6 (Basic); each extra state $10/month.
- Typical onboarding: 5-7 business days after data handoff.
Church and nonprofit payroll is unlike standard small-business payroll. You may compensate clergy, staff, and occasional speakers; operate across multiple campuses; and rely on fund accounting. This guide explains how to set up clean classifications, keep filings on time, and avoid year-end surprises-without adding administrative overhead.
Roles & Classification (W-2 vs 1099)
Staff employees → W-2
Employees on a regular schedule, directed by leadership, should be paid via W-2. This covers administrators, finance coordinators, music staff, and most ministry roles.
Contractors → 1099
Use 1099 only for true independent engagements (e.g., one-off speakers or specialized vendors). When in doubt, default to W-2-misclassification can trigger penalties.
Volunteers & stipends
Stipends need careful handling; we help you choose the right setup to avoid downstream tax issues.
Clergy Housing Allowance (where applicable)
Track the allowance with a dedicated field so it’s handled consistently in each run. Our pre-run checks verify setup before payroll posts, and year-end validations keep W-2 output consistent.
Multi-State & Multi-Campus Considerations
If your ministry spans states or opens a new campus, registrations and SUI rates must be in place before the first run. We add states for a flat $10/month each and tag employees by campus so your reports map to fund/designations.
Taxes, Filings, and Year-End
- Federal and state filings included (940/941, SUI, withholding).
- W-2/1099 e-delivery is standard; paper mailing optional.
- Quarter-end reconciliation and audit-ready exports for board reporting.
AI-Assisted Accuracy (Pre-Run & Year-End)
- Anomaly flags for outlier hours/rates or new designations.
- Missing state ID reminders as you expand.
- W-2/1099 pre-flight validation to prevent reissues.
Pricing & Timelines
- Full Payroll (CPA-reviewed): $50/month base + $7 per employee.
- Basic Payroll: $40 + $6.
- Extra states: $10/month each.
- Most organizations go live in 5-7 business days after data handoff.
Quick Setup Checklist
- Employee/contractor roster and pay schedules
- Banking + tax accounts; existing state IDs
- Prior quarter returns and year-to-date totals
- Clergy allowance details (if applicable)
- Campus/fund tags for reporting
Serving Columbus, Ohio 43215
We support churches and nonprofits nationwide-single-campus or multi-state-including ministries in Columbus, Ohio 43215.
FAQs
Do you support clergy allowances?
Yes-use the dedicated field; we QA during setup.
Can you handle multiple campuses?
Yes-tag by campus/fund; add states for $10/month.
Do you file all payroll taxes?
Yes-federal and state filings included.
How fast can we switch?
Typically 5-7 business days after data handoff.
Are there per-run fees?
No-flat monthly pricing.
Need reliable payroll management? Our payroll processing services make it easy to handle taxes, payments, and filings-so you can focus on your business.
Looking for straightforward payroll pricing?
Our plans start at $40/month base + $6 per employee/month, with no per-run fees. Get your first month of bookkeeping free when you sign up.
See Pricing.
Managing church payroll? Our church payroll services offer flat-rate pricing with no per-run fees, including direct deposit, tax filings, and year-end W-2/1099 e-delivery-designed to fit your ministry’s budget.
Looking for payroll services tailored to your location? Our payroll processing services by location offer flat-rate pricing and compliance across all 50 states, including city-specific tax filings and support for remote teams.
Stay organized and tax-ready year-round with our flat-rate monthly bookkeeping services.
If you’re behind on your books, our catch-up bookkeeping services can help you get current fast-no stress, no mess.
