Xero to QuickBooks: When It Makes Sense (And When It Doesn’t)
Xero and QuickBooks both deliver excellent bookkeeping functionality. But as your business grows, one may fit better than the other. Many companies switch from Xero to QuickBooks for deeper U.S. compliance, stronger reporting, or broader app integrations. This guide helps you decide if the switch is right for you and how to manage the migration process smoothly.
Manage multi-channel accounting through expert QuickBooks support.
When Moving to QuickBooks Makes Sense
Consider switching if you need:
- Better U.S. tax and payroll integration: QuickBooks syncs directly with IRS, state filings, and Gusto payroll.
- More accountant familiarity : CPAs in the U.S. typically prefer QuickBooks for collaboration and review.
- Advanced reporting: Custom dashboards, classes, and consolidation features in QBO Advanced.
- E-commerce integrations: Amazon, Shopify, and Stripe connectors run more seamlessly in QuickBooks.
For growing businesses, these advantages can outweigh the migration effort.
When Staying with Xero Might Be Better
Keep Xero if:
- You operate globally and need multi-currency support.
- You already use strong integrations built around Xero’s ecosystem.
- Your accountant prefers Xero’s layout and reports.
- You manage simple, single-entity bookkeeping with no complex structures.
Switching for minor issues rarely justifies the time investment.
Migration Checklist
If you decide to move, follow this sequence:
- Export data from Xero: customers, vendors, chart of accounts, and trial balance.
- Reconcile and lock all prior periods to protect historical accuracy.
- Set up QuickBooks Online: mirror account names and types from Xero.
- Import your data: use a certified migration tool or accountant.
- Review balances: verify P&L, Balance Sheet, and AR/AP totals.
- Reconnect bank feeds and apps to resume automation.
Migration usually takes a few hours with the right tools.
Learn more about our professional bookkeeping services.
Compare Xero and QuickBooks bookkeeping services side by side.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Migrating before reconciling Xero books.
- Renaming accounts during import, breaking report continuity.
- Forgetting to reassign opening balances in QuickBooks.
- Deleting your Xero subscription before validation.
Avoiding these steps ensures a clean, compliant transition.
The Verdict
Switch to QuickBooks when scale, reporting, or collaboration needs exceed Xero’s simplicity. Stay with Xero if your workflow is already efficient and compliant. The right choice depends on your business model, not the software alone.
Xero vs. QuickBooks: Which Fits Your Team?
Migrating to QuickBooks Online: A No-Drama Plan
FAQs
How long does Xero to QuickBooks migration take?
Usually one to two business days, depending on file size.
Can I transfer all my historical data?
Yes, most migration tools support up to two years of history automatically, with older data stored in backup.
Will switching affect my tax reporting?
No. If your books are reconciled before migration, tax reporting stays consistent.
Should I hire a professional for migration?
Yes. Certified QuickBooks ProAdvisors ensure complete and verified data transfer.
Need help fixing or optimizing your QuickBooks setup?
Get a free consultation with RemoteBooksOnline and discover how our QuickBooks bookkeeping experts keep your books clean, accurate, and tax-ready.
Start Your Free Consultation →
Need help fixing or optimizing your QuickBooks setup? Get a free consultation with RemoteBooksOnline and discover how our QuickBooks bookkeeping experts keep your books clean, accurate, and tax-ready. Start Your Free Consultation
